Last visit was: Fri Aug 14, 2009 2:22 am It is currently Fri Aug 14, 2009 2:22 am











 [ 37 posts ]  Go to page Previous  1, 2, 3, 4
Author Message
 Post subject: Re: Summer Clear Out!
Posted: Sat Aug 01, 2009 2:53 am 
Malcolm Macdonald

Joined: Sat Feb 21, 2009 8:35 pm
Posts: 85
TOPGOONER49 wrote:
We are dealing with Rosicky here, I think you seem to have forgotten that his original injury was described as minor by Arsene Wenger, and we were told that he was going to be out for about a fortnight.
Two years later and here we are.

Yes, here we are. This doesn't prove my point wrong.
TOPGOONER49 wrote:
Organisation is only part of being a Captain, and to be honest, the fact that Kolo Toure made history in the Champions League whilst being partnered by Senderos PROVES that he was more than able to the organizer, and did organize on many occasions.

And the fact Gallas is doing it now PROVES Kolo was no longer the organizer.
TOPGOONER49 wrote:
No, but seriously, how old are you? The way you are talking would suggest that you cannot be older than 16 – it just is not possible.

My age has nothing to do with how I write.
TOPGOONER49 wrote:
It does when you are in an already young team, and playing at Centre Back in the best and biggest competitions in the world...

And it helps to have be playing the man who can help the most in the best and biggest competition in the world....
TOPGOONER49 wrote:
Yes... they are also inexperienced compared to my dad, but comparing Silvestre and Toure are two entirely different things.

True, as is trying to saying Toure's experience somehow makes up for his shortcomings as a player and the fact he doesn't slot in beside Gallas, who is the only CB with an assured starting spot.

TOPGOONER49 wrote:
This is where your naivety shows... HE HAS NOT YET PLAYED A COMPETITIVE GAME FOR ARSENAL, YOU HAVE NO IDEA ABOUT HIM!

He's played for Ajax. He's captained Ajax. I'll accept that as potential to succeed, as well as the fact he does have aerial ability, as has been said from people who follow the Dutch league.
TOPGOONER49 wrote:
I went to caps lock to emphasize importance...

I liked it.
TOPGOONER49 wrote:
It is true that Senderos and Djourou command the air, but Senderos simply does not have the right mentality to make it at Arsenal – he had a poor game against Liverpool and had a breakdown. Drogba made him his bitch. I have already explained to you that Vermaelen and his aerial ability are around the same as Kolo, but to be honest, you will just have to wait and see.

I agree, Senderos is in put up or get the f##k out territory, but he still is slotting in the position that is needed.
TOPGOONER49 wrote:
Our whole squad will potentially die tomorrow... notice what I did?

You used hyperbole and a false analogy. Nice.

TOPGOONER49 wrote:
It quite clearly is, hence the reason we had Adebayor in the first place, Bendtner on the bench, and look to be signing this Chamakh guy. In fact, playing Van Persie up front alone is disastrous.

And before him there was Henry, who isn't at all like Ade.

As seen when Van Persie single-handedly saved the team for a month. Yes, it was horrible.


Top
   
 
 Post subject: Re: Summer Clear Out!
Posted: Sat Aug 01, 2009 6:08 pm 
George Graham

Joined: Sun Feb 15, 2009 4:34 pm
Posts: 155
Quote:
Yes, here we are. This doesn't prove my point wrong.

It does, however, prove your point as unreliable.

Quote:
And the fact Gallas is doing it now PROVES Kolo was no longer the organizer.

Doing it against who? We have not played one competitive game, and just conceded a goal against Athletico Madrid that was solely due to Gallas and his bad positioning.

Nice.

Quote:
My age has nothing to do with how I write.

It does, however, alter the way in which you form an opinion.

Quote:
And it helps to have be playing the man who can help the most in the best and biggest competition in the world....

What?

Quote:
True, as is trying to saying Toure's experience somehow makes up for his shortcomings as a player and the fact he doesn't slot in beside Gallas, who is the only CB with an assured starting spot.

Firstly, thanks for accepting the fact that you were wrong in comparing Toure to Silvestre... secondly, today proved that it was not necessarily Toure’s fault for a lot of the bad positioning. Let’s not forget how much we missed him when he was at the African Cup Nations, as well as Gallas’ awful positioning today for Madrid’s goal.

Quote:
He's played for Ajax. He's captained Ajax. I'll accept that as potential to succeed, as well as the fact he does have aerial ability, as has been said from people who follow the Dutch league.

Senderos captained Switzerland.

Say no more.

Quote:
And before him there was Henry, who isn't at all like Ade.

Exactly... notice how we haven’t won anything since Henry left?

Well spotted, son.

Quote:
As seen when Van Persie single-handedly saved the team for a month. Yes, it was horrible.

Oh yeah, another thing. Wenger also said that Van Persie has NEVER played up front alone. Once again, another great point made.


Top
   
 
 Post subject: Re: Summer Clear Out!
Posted: Sat Aug 01, 2009 10:27 pm 
Malcolm Macdonald

Joined: Sat Feb 21, 2009 8:35 pm
Posts: 85
TOPGOONER49 wrote:
It does, however, prove your point as unreliable.

No. All it proves is Rosicky has injury problems. Doesn't change the fact if he comes back to play this year he's an addition to the squad.
TOPGOONER49 wrote:
Doing it against who? We have not played one competitive game, and just conceded a goal against Athletico Madrid that was solely due to Gallas and his bad positioning.

Doing it all last year when he playing.
TOPGOONER49 wrote:
It does, however, alter the way in which you form an opinion.

No. Experience and knowledge affect opinions. Not age.
TOPGOONER49 wrote:
What?

Toure doesn't help Arsenal the most in the league. Other players who fit the role of aerial control help.
TOPGOONER49 wrote:
Firstly, thanks for accepting the fact that you were wrong in comparing Toure to Silvestre...

I wasn't. You're saying Toure's experience gives him a pass. It doesn't, like it doesn't give Silvestre a pass. When you're past it, you're past it.
TOPGOONER49 wrote:
secondly, today proved that it was not necessarily Toure’s fault for a lot of the bad positioning. Let’s not forget how much we missed him when he was at the African Cup Nations, as well as Gallas’ awful positioning today for Madrid’s goal.

And let's not forget how awful Toure was after the ANC.
TOPGOONER49 wrote:
Senderos captained Switzerland.

Switzerland isn't the same. Not even close.
TOPGOONER49 wrote:
Exactly... notice how we haven’t won anything since Henry left?

So why in the hell do we need a tall striker?
TOPGOONER49 wrote:
Oh yeah, another thing. Wenger also said that Van Persie has NEVER played up front alone. Once again, another great point made.

That's because Wenger counts second strikers, which isn't what were talking about.


Top
   
 
 Post subject: Re: Summer Clear Out!
Posted: Sun Aug 02, 2009 2:05 am 
George Graham

Joined: Sun Feb 15, 2009 4:34 pm
Posts: 155
Quote:
No. All it proves is Rosicky has injury problems. Doesn't change the fact if he comes back to play this year he's an addition to the squad.

Yes, proving he has injury problems would usually also prove that the chances of him, going by your theory, being sold (LOL), is very likely... therefore meaning an additional winger should be bought.

Quote:
Doing it all last year when he playing.

Yet we still had the worst defensive record out of the top 4?

Nice, good job Gallas!

Quote:
No. Experience and knowledge affect opinions. Not age.

Yes, generally, the older you are the more experienced you are.

Good one.

Quote:
I wasn't. You're saying Toure's experience gives him a pass. It doesn't, like it doesn't give Silvestre a pass. When you're past it, you're past it.

I used Toure's experience as ONE attribute regarding what we are losing by selling him. Toure is more experienced WITH Arsenal than anybody you can name (who is still in the squad).

Quote:
Switzerland isn't the same. Not even close.

I know... captaining your Nation is a much bigger achievement than captaining a club side.

Quote:
That's because Wenger counts second strikers, which isn't what were talking about.

Second what?

Second strikers?

OK :-)


Top
   
 
 Post subject: Re: Summer Clear Out!
Posted: Sun Aug 02, 2009 4:57 pm 
Malcolm Macdonald

Joined: Sat Feb 21, 2009 8:35 pm
Posts: 85
TOPGOONER49 wrote:
Yes, proving he has injury problems would usually also prove that the chances of him, going by your theory, being sold (LOL), is very likely... therefore meaning an additional winger should be bought.

No. That has nothing to do with what I'm saying.
TOPGOONER49 wrote:
Yet we still had the worst defensive record out of the top 4?

Nice, good job Gallas!

And somehow Toure gets a pass?
TOPGOONER49 wrote:
Yes, generally, the older you are the more experienced you are.

Ya. Doesn't mean I don't have experience because I'm younger than you.
TOPGOONER49 wrote:
I used Toure's experience as ONE attribute regarding what we are losing by selling him. Toure is more experienced WITH Arsenal than anybody you can name (who is still in the squad).

You used it as his greatest trait, which I agree, it is. But 15m is more valuable than that.
TOPGOONER49 wrote:
I know... captaining your Nation is a much bigger achievement than captaining a club side.

Except when that club has the greatest pressure in a country while captaining a small country a few times when other players were gone isn't.
TOPGOONER49 wrote:
Second what?

Second strikers?

OK :-)

You're right. So you're point about needing a striker who can play alone is bullshit since Arsenal always plays with a second striker.

Good one.


Top
   
 
 Post subject: Re: Summer Clear Out!
Posted: Sun Aug 02, 2009 8:00 pm 
George Graham

Joined: Sun Feb 15, 2009 4:34 pm
Posts: 155
Quote:
And somehow Toure gets a pass?

What?

I never once said Toure had a good season, I just said that by selling him we are losing much more than just pure ability. It’s you acting like Gallas is the king of defence.

Quote:
Ya. Doesn't mean I don't have experience because I'm younger than you.

But to be honest, you really do have a childish naïve mentality. I mean come on, Vermealen better than Toure without even seeing him play?

Quote:
You used it as his greatest trait, which I agree, it is. But 15m is more valuable than that.

I disagree. Name me a defender that we can get who:
- Has equal ability to Toure
- Has the same determination
- Loves Arsenal
- Guarenteed chemistry

For £15m.

Quote:
Except when that club has the greatest pressure in a country while captaining a small country a few times when other players were gone isn't.

To be honest, captaining ANY country is a much bigger pressure than captaining Ajax. Ajax are hardly pressured in the League, because they aren’t even expected to win it.

Quote:
You're right. So you're point about needing a striker who can play alone is bullshit since Arsenal always plays with a second striker.

When did I say that we need a striker who can play alone? I said we need a tall striker so that we don’t have to change our entire mentality.

Twisting words, eh?

Poor!


Top
   
 
 Post subject: Re: Summer Clear Out!
Posted: Wed Aug 05, 2009 12:31 am 
Malcolm Macdonald

Joined: Sat Feb 21, 2009 8:35 pm
Posts: 85
TOPGOONER49 wrote:
What?

I never once said Toure had a good season, I just said that by selling him we are losing much more than just pure ability. It’s you acting like Gallas is the king of defence.

And I believe what is lost is worth 16m.
TOPGOONER49 wrote:
But to be honest, you really do have a childish naïve mentality. I mean come on, Vermealen better than Toure without even seeing him play?

I said he can be equal, and is plays a more useful style. Well at least that's what I meant

TOPGOONER49 wrote:
I disagree. Name me a defender that we can get who:
- Has equal ability to Toure
- Has the same determination
- Loves Arsenal
- Guarenteed chemistry

We don't need Toure's ability. What is needed is someone of Campbell's ability. Determination is great except when he constantly gets played out of position, loving Arsenal doesn't make you a good defender, and he had no chemistry with Gallas.

For 15m someone like Naldo can be brought in, who is aerial dominant and experienced.
TOPGOONER49 wrote:
To be honest, captaining ANY country is a much bigger pressure than captaining Ajax. Ajax are hardly pressured in the League, because they aren’t even expected to win it.

I'll concede that.
TOPGOONER49 wrote:
When did I say that we need a striker who can play alone? I said we need a tall striker so that we don’t have to change our entire mentality.

Sorry, messed up your writing.

A tall striker isn't needed. As you said, Arsenal was better with Henry, who doesn't fit that mold.


Top
   
 
 [ 37 posts ]  Moderators: Manager, Director Go to page Previous  1, 2, 3, 4


Who is online

Users browsing this forum: No registered users and 0 guests


You cannot post new topics in this forum
You cannot reply to topics in this forum
You cannot edit your posts in this forum
You cannot delete your posts in this forum
You cannot post attachments in this forum

Jump to:  



LINKS : Arsenal Action Blog : Live Premierleague Scores

Banner Designed by Kre8ors Studio

Powered by phpBB © 2000, 2002, 2005, 2007 phpBB Group
Theme created StylerBB.net & kodeki